Overview

Title: The second life of cotton - and how quality decides its future
Date: Wednesday 11 November 2026
Duration: 46 minutes

Summary

Sponsored by Uster Technologies AG

Recycled cotton is becoming increasingly important as the textile industry strives for circularity, yet uncertainty about its quality remains a major obstacle to broader use. Mechanical recycling alters fibre properties, challenging the way quality has traditionally been understood. This talk aims to shed light on these changes by demonstrating how systematic monitoring of key quality parameters can create clarity. The presentation introduces the concept of a standardised quality classification framework to improve comparability within the recycled cotton market. Such a framework could help establish a common language between recyclers, spinners, and downstream stakeholders. Ultimately, the talk aims to stimulate discussion on how systematic quality management can support the future role of recycled cotton in sustainable textile production.

Speakers

  • Christine Woerner, Uster Technologies AG
Transcript

This transcription has been AI generated and therefore may have some inaccuracies.

The second life of cotton - and how quality decides its future

Recycled cotton is becoming increasingly important as the textile industry strives for circularity, yet uncertainty about its quality remains a major obstacle to broader use.

Madelaine Thomas

Good afternoon. Good afternoon, good morning, or good evening, and welcome to day two of Textile and Apparel Circularity Week. I'm Madeline Thomas, managing. Director of the World Textile Information Network, the intelligence provider to the textile and apparel supply chain. So yesterday we started at the design and material stage, looking at how products and materials are designed for circularity. If you missed any, you can catch up on demand via the event website on that. And today we move onto the factory floor. Our theme is technology and production. Where we're putting circular technologies to work in manufacturing facilities, we'll hear about how recycled fiber quality can be measured and compared, why standardisation matters across the value chain, how manufacturers are adding circular technology to the facilities they already have, and why water is a circularity challenge the industry too often overlooks. But before we start, I'd like to thank again the to the organisations that made this week possible. So Ursa Technologies, our innovation sponsor. Who actually opened today's program for us, and interlude our event partner. Open today's program for us, and Intelluit, our event partner, who will join this afternoon's panel. I'd also like to thank our friends of conference, ITMA 2027, and EcoMondo. A quick reminder to put your questions into the Q&A box at any time, and remember that every session is available on demand afterwards for WTIN members and premium pass holders as well. So to kick off today, I'm delighted to introduce our. First speaker, our innovation sponsor, Christina Warner, is head of tech. Our innovation sponsor, Christina Wanner, is head of textile technology, Switzerland, at Uster Technologies. Christine will show how systematic monitoring of key quality parameters can bring clarity and introduce the idea of standardised quality classification for recycled cotton, which is a common language for recyclers, spinners, and everyone further down the chain. Christine, I'll pass over to you now.

Christine Woerner

Yeah. All right. Thank, thank you very much, Madeline, and hello everybody. So I will share my presentation. Perfect. Thanks, Christine. All right. Thanks a lot. Okay. So I will speak in the next. Half hour, 20 minutes, about Cotton's second life. Or how to control and classify the main ingredient of any recycled textile product—the actual fibers—and in this case, the recycled fibers, which has additional challenges. Let's say. So I will just dive in and share with you. A true story from the industry that was published in. July in the Cohen Textile Journal, and it was found by my colleague Teresa Rita. And this story is about a spinning mill who tried to use recycled material. So they bought certified—that's really important—certified recycled material. They had one trial run. They did not succeed. They had two more rents. They still didn't succeed. And what does it mean? It means they had yarn breaks going up 35%. And the yarn breaks are one parameter to define the efficiency of your spinning mill. So that means the efficiency went down, and also the quality went down. That means the specification of the finished. Fabric has not been within the. Of the finished fabric, have not been within their limits anymore. So that means a financial loss, and also a loss of trust in recycled material. So this spinning mill went back to virgin material and never tried again, and probably never will. So the learning from here is that the certification is. Of course, one part of the recycled material, but it only tells you. Where the fiber comes from. You also have to measure the fiber and get all the information about the quality of this fiber that you can actually process it in your mill. This example, I will come back after the explanation how we think you can. Handle the quality. And then we will come back to this example, and I will show you some application examples related to the story I just told you. So, some general points or thoughts is we do not have to talk anymore about if recycling cotton is coming. Or not, because that was the content of many recent discussions. But this discussion is finished because it's not a trend; it will stay. The targets are set, there are regulations coming, and volumes are being built. At the same time, many brands are setting very ambitious targets for using the recycled materials in their products. Increasing the amount of recycled cotton raises an important question. Important question: How can we scale up? The business and use the recycled fibres efficiently while maintaining the quality of our final products? It is all about the correct application, and I will come back to this many times because this is really crucial. So, it's about the correct application of your raw material, and you already make a choice for virgin cotton, so the mills are. Using to evaluate what cotton is correct for the application, but now we have to implement a routine also for this new raw material, which is the recycled fiber. For us at Uster, and really for me personally, a very important topic is the terminology, because still, and we did several. Applications and speeches on this topic, but still, if you speak with stakeholders, it's not crystal clear. Let's say it's a little clearer, or maybe much clearer, but still not crystal clear. So we have to use the same terms, or at least we need to mean the same things. An easy example is the pre-consumer waste, because it can be everything. From the yarn waste in the mill up to the unsold finished garments. This is too big a category. It's not possible because the quality can be very different, and I will show examples about this later. So we speak about post-industrial waste, and I think more and more companies are doing the same now, and also. So here, very important, post-industrial waste is yarn waste from your production. And it's fabric waste from your fabric production. So it is not, for example, fiber waste from your mill. That is what we call soft waste, and it's not certified as recycled material. Then we have the pre-consumer and the post-consumer. So for me, it's really important that we use the same language. Only then we have the transparency in. The textile change. Now, what are the challenges? That the producers are facing with the mechanically recycled fibres? And I want to focus especially on one point. So, what you see here on the left side is the recycled material, and you can already see some yarn pieces. That is one challenge. Here, if you take them out, this is. Your yarn pieces on the left side. You have your fabric piece. Pieces on the left side. I mean, even the best open material will still have some fabric pieces for sure. You will have yarn pieces. You have in your, and I will talk a little more about the short fiber content and the yarn, the fiber length in particular, which we see here in this middle picture. Then you also have. You have the color variation. You have foreign contamination which is still in the recycled material. What you also have is the richness of the material. So you cannot avoid having, in 100% recycled cotton material, you will always have other fibers. I mean, raw material like polyester, or you cannot avoid that. It's what we call the richness. And then you also have the NAPS. We do not talk about the NAPS now, because that would be too wide an area. What I would like to focus a little more is here on the fiber length of the recycled material, and then the short fibers, because they define how you process your fiber material. Now, if you have a look here, this is a very nice end-aligned staple diagram. So, why are? Are we using it, or why? Why do we use it? It's it's used. Are we using it, or why do we use it? It's used long time for virgin cotton. And what you're doing is, when you're testing, is you use a fiber sample, and then you start collecting single fiber per fiber, and you start with the longest one on the left side. That is a very common picture. What you see here, so you have the very longest fibers here on the left side, and then you go down the fibers. Charter and charter, and at one point, this is. Gets shorter and shorter, and at one point, this is this red arrow here. The fiber is 12.5 millimeter or half an inch, and then everything on the left, left side, right side, sorry, is called a short fiber by definition, not by us, by everyone else. This is virgin cotton. For recycled cotton. The left arrow, the red arrow, will be pushed to the left side because the percentage of your short fiber is much bigger, and this is one of the main challenges you have with recycled material. This is why I want to focus a little more on this. And then the other challenge is the mean fiber length of your staple or of your fiber material, and you can imagine that's an easy calculation if this. The short part is much bigger. Then, of course, your mean fiber length gets shorter, and that has a big influence on how you process your fiber material. Right. Just want to be sure I don't miss anything. Now, what are the key factors which are influencing the fiber length and all other fiber characteristics? One main factor influencing the fiber material is the tearing process of your tearing machines. So you put in the clippings of your waste material, and then, depending on the intensity of the opening and the machine configuration (how many rollers and the one), you will have your fiber material. A big challenge here is that. So far, you cannot test this material. I mean, you need an experienced operator of this machine, and he will just—if you visited a tearing line or a mill producing recycled fibers—then you saw that they are just taking a fiber sample out of the process, and then they look at it, and it's mainly visual, because during the process. I'm not aware. That you can actually test the fiber length, for example. But then, of course, after the tearing process is finished, then you can test it. But then also the process is finished, so you have what you have. Then the other influence on the fiber characteristic is the waste type, so it makes a difference on your fiber material if the waste is coming from post-industrial. Or let's say post-consumer waste. Then you have the biobased. Consumer waste. Then you have the fiber quality itself, the fiber length above the threshold to maintain spinability and yarn strength. All the neps, for example, are an influence on the fiber characteristic, and then of course the opening degree. So because and there you have a dependency, and that makes it even more challenging. So for example, the more You tear your material, or the more aggressive you set your tearing line, you will have a good opening degree. That means no more yarn pieces, no more fabric pieces. But on the other hand, your fiber length, as you can imagine, the fiber length most probably will go down. But everyone is working on optimizing this process. So also, of course, the manufacturers, the machine manufacturers, are working on optimizing. Optimizing that process. So this is one of the key developments. Or where the key developments are going at the moment. All right. So, so successful recycling is not about increasing the recycled content. It is really about understanding the material and then match the process to it. So, if we go. From or a takeaway from this short introduction to the actual fiber quality for me would be that measuring the fiber reality means test your single fibers fiber by fiber. This is very important. And also, I mean, if you are measuring manually, you can measure maybe even.

Christine Woerner

Some hundreds of fibers are a lot, so if you go to the Instrument measurement, you can test a lot more. That's an advantage if you test with a fiber testing instrument. For our instrument, we are testing 3,000 fibers per one single sample, and we, since recycling fibers have a lot of variation, we always recommend to test 10. Samples per one test, or subsamples, but I know it's a long trial. But I mean it's worth the information. Let's say you will never be able to test as much with manual testing, and this means that your test, if you do manual testing, your test may be biased because it really depends on this single crib you're doing where you take out some samples. Then, second would be read. Key parameters, and of course really understand what it's telling you. So read the results and understand what does it mean, and do the analysis based on results. And in the last step, make a decision and assign a quality class benchmarking. That means you need a reference somehow that you are able. To say this is good or bad. Or better. We do not like to say good or bad because it depends entirely on the application. So we prefer: this is appropriate for the planned process, or use another plan. Make really result-based decisions. And if you compare. If you want a benchmark. You have always two possibilities. So you can have your own benchmark, meaning doing a relative comparison. So let's say if you use recycling material continuously, you can use your own data. If you know a material worked, you keep the own data, and if you test it the next time, you compare the current data with your. Old data, which worked, and that is a relative comparison. And you can do that. That will work. We try, or we offer to our customers what we call the Uster Recycles Hyper Matrix. This is an absolute comparison, so you have a reference. The reference is the matrix, and you can benchmark your own material now with this matrix. And I wanna show you now how. And I want to show you now how we did the matrix, and also explain how it can be used. The matrix is based on a global database of recycled fiber samples. We measured it, obviously, with our own measuring instrument. It's an AFIIS. The AFIIS is a single fiber measurement instrument where you can measure also recycled fibers. And if you have an atheist. Also recycled fibers, and if you have an Avis, you can also add a recycled module, and you will get more informative quality data for it. But this is not so much about the instrument; it's really more about the reference and benchmarking your recycled material. So here you can see, I mean, for many spinning mills, the recycled. The material is new, and we get a lot of inquiries about how can they use the recycled material, or can they use it at all? What is the quality? And we tell the customer just send us the material and we will test it. And in this way, we collected many, many samples, recycled samples, and a lot of different samples also. So we are in a very good position. And at one point, we said we will now evaluate, analyze all this material, and do something useful with it, and actually share this data with the textile industry, with the stakeholders, not only our customers. So, based on that, we developed the Uster, we call it the Uster Recycling Fiber Matrix, and put the data into practice. You can say so the data. Data set gives you a. Into practice, you can say. So the dataset gives you a very solid foundation, and based on this data, the matrix actually offers two different evaluation systems, where we can have a look. What you now actually see in the diagram is the percentage of samples which are in the database. So the blue one, the 23%, that is the post-industrial waste. Then the 39%, the CREE. Percentage here—that is the post-consumer waste—and the purple, or yeah, purple—I would say the 38% is what we call the pre-consumer waste. Now, if you keep the colors in mind, we can go to the next diagram. You see the same colors, but now it is already parameter-related. So this. Related. So this is an example we use here. You can see the fiber length of these results. So every sample was tested, and this is already the result of these tests. Again, we have the green, which is the post-consumer. We have the purple, the pre-consumer, and then the post-industrial blue percentage. And you can see here, step by step, the fiber length. So the mean fiber length was here five millimeter. That is ridiculous. You cannot work with it. And then here we go up to 19 millimeters. So, and we have here the step by step: five, six millimeters, seven millimeters. So that means all the samples in this. It's not a class. It's. The seven millimeters. Had this mean value? You can do the same evaluation for short fibers, for naps, for upper quarter lengths. All the parameters can be evaluated in this way. Now, what you can—it already gives you a little picture here, a little analysis or evaluation, because you can already see the green, the post-consumer one, is on the left side. It has the short. Number one is on the left side. It has the shorter fiber lengths, mean fiber lengths. Then you have here the purple one, and the post-industrial gives you the best or the longest mean fiber lengths. Now, in the next step, we go and now you can already see the matrix. So, what we do now? We relate. You have here the axes again, and this is exactly the same. Let me go back. So you go here from 5 millimeter to 19 millimeters, and we go here even 0 millimeters, but that is a class now to 70 millimeters and longer. In our experience, and in many discussions with customers, and also the evaluation of the database. We made nothing. Evaluation of the database. We made now classes. We installed classes. So this is a logarithmical axis. So you have from 0 to 12 millimeters, the first class, very short fiber lengths, probably coming from post-consumer waste. You have the 12 to 14 millimeters, 14 to 17, and then everything which is long. Unfortunately, you cannot only use to make a good decision. You cannot only make use one parameter. So, what we do, we go from one-dimensional to two-dimensional. So, we add now to the metrics another parameter. We use here the short fiber content. It's one of the most challenging parameters, and this means. If you remember the short, the staple diagram from before, so now 45 here you can see the different percentages. 45 of your percentage of your staple diagram are short fibers. That means of the tested samples of your fibers, 45% are shorter than. 0.5 millimeters. Then you have here the next class another class, and the best, or the class. I know it's the other way around. Sorry. This is the best one. So 45 is less than 65. I'm sorry. And here you can see it's the gray is the non-existent quality. So if you have 80% and more, that is unspinnable. Then you need to look for another application, I would say. Because then only 20% are longer fibers than 12.5. So this is how you read the matrix. You don't have to deeply understand everything, because we made a color code, and the color code also goes back to the first evaluation again. So you have blue for excellent quality. You have the purple for good quality. You have the yellow for fairly quality, and the green for poor, and you don't. And the greens are poor. And you don't have to dig deep into the understanding or how it's built or the background or anything or the testing. You can settle on let's only use purple quality, good quality. That's good enough for me. Or if you want to do, depending on the application, you need the best quality, then you can say we trade. Only the blue quality. So we wanted to make it as simple as possible, right? And now we are adding actual classes or description of classes, and this is how we want to help our customers or the industry to what can you do with the quality? Because excellent quality is not enough; you need to do what to do with it. So now we name. And we gave each quality. A name. So, I mean, class A—it's a simple name: A, B, C, D. We didn't come up with anything better, so we just settled for A, B, C, D. And if you go back, let's have a look here. Let's look at, for example, this class: 40 millimeter to 70 millimeter, and then a short fiber content. Let's use this one. Forty-five percent. Let's use this one: 45%, 65%. That would be here, 40 to 17, the class B. What does it mean? You blend your virgin fibers, you blend your recycled materials, virgin fibers, and you can then produce the ring carded or compact yarns for casual needs or shirt. That is the starting point. If If you want to increase the quality, you increase the virgin fibers. You can increase the twist. There are many different ways of increasing, or you can also, how do you call it, downcycle, which is also a possibility. And not a quality seal; it's not a quality label. It might make sense for some fibers to downcycle. So it really depends on the application again, and this is. The starting point, and starting from this, you can then decide again result-based decisions what you want to do with the product. Now we combine everything, and this is then what we call the matrix. So you have now in your recycled fiber matrix: you have here the fiber length, you have here the short fiber content of your sample, and then you have here the classes. Why do we have? Two letters because you have two parameters. You have the a which is here for the short fiber content. And for example, in this yellow glass, you have the C, which would then be the first letter is always for the fiber length, because also the fiber length, the reference is not changing. It's always the x-axis is always staying the same. And then you can exchange here the quality parameters. So the second letter is for this bi-axis, and you have an easy tool and a reference to compare your fiber materials. And I'm happy to answer all questions you might have in our Q&A lesson later on, Q&A session. Sorry. Now I want to come back. We are already running out of time very quickly. I want to come back to the. Introducing story or the story at the very beginning with with a meal, doing three try. Beginning with with a mill, doing three dry runs with the recycled material. So what I have now here is an application example with three different materials. And the thing is, all this is recycled. So you buy recycled material, you can get either of this, and it will all be certified. In this example, number one is post-industrial. We choose. Deliberately, very different material—material with big differences—to really make a case. So, one is post-industrial, two is pre-consumer, and three is post-consumer. We did our test, single fiber test, and then we use the results and put. The results into the matrix we just had a look at, and if we go back, look at the white one. That is the number one, the post-industrial waste. In the matrix, this is the best material with the longest mean fiber length and the lowest short fiber content. You can see it falls here in the class AA. Going back one more time, let's take number three. It's the post-industrial. It's the biggest challenge to tear. And you can see it falls here in the class DC, so it has a short fiber length, sorry, a mean fiber length. Here we have the values of 10 millimeters, and then here, and then you have the short fiber content of 74 percentage. And this is why it falls into this class. So, if you have that big a difference in your recycled material, you need to know. So, you have to test it, and you need to know for your process. If you want to know anything about the matrix, or if you want to have your own matrix, you can scan the QR code, and you will be directed to this application report, which is publicly available for everyone. So Uster has an Insight app. You can log. Onto our usto com website and go to ano it's real. Go to annu360q. Com website and go to. I know it's 360Q. So if you use the QR code, you will be directed to the right site. And every publication we do, we share not only with our customers, we share with all the textile stakeholders. Okay. And finally, takeaway: what I would like you to remember is first measure. The material. Understand. The result, and then make a decision—a result-based decision. The value of the recycled fiber is not defined one by one, so that means parameters are dependent or have dependencies. You need to see the full picture, not only one key parameter. The combination determines how it. Can be processed, then. You need to make the decision on the optimal blending and the process settings. And our mantra in Uster really is: you can only improve what you can measure. And we are not getting tired of explaining how you can actually do that. Right. Final statement. I would say. What comes next? The cross has to come from the yeah from the pre and especially the post-consumer textiles. I mean, now most of the companies are focusing on the post-industrial, and this is very good because we are already at the at the point that the post-industrial material can be added. And blended, and and. Added and blended, and a nice end product can be produced out of this. But we have to focus really on the post-consumer, or the next step must be to make the post-consumer scalable. If we really want to do or add sustainability, another level of sustainability, let's say. And then, what it will take is a shared quality language. Plant-based fiber. Shared quality language, plant side fiber at intake, agreed glass limits written into contracts, and then blends engineered to a target yarn quality instead of a target percentage. That's really important. Certification tells us where the fiber comes from. This is also important, but the classification tells us what it can do. So the cotton second life begins at the moment when the. The whole value chains is speaking the same quality language, as you can see in the red box. That's my final statement. Enabling a second life for cotton begins with a shared quality language across the value chain. So this is all from my side. Thank you very much for listening, and I will hand over now to Madeline again. Thank you, Christine, for that presentation. That was really. Interesting. I think the matrix is really powerful.

Madelaine Thomas

So thanks for sharing that with us all. And I agree on that. The same language for um for for quality. Um, I want to get into our audience questions because, as you said, we are running out of time. Um, and I guess one of them relates back to that shared language. Actually, um, we we have a message here that says, um, I've often used. Pre-consumer and post-industrial as the same thing. What it says. What does Uster? How does Uster differentiate between pre-consumer and post-industrial waste?

Christine Woerner

So we have this terminology, which we also published, and for us, the the difference is really that the post-industrial waste ends. Where you start making your garments, and for us the pre-consumer is already garments, but which have not reached the consumer. So it has an additional challenge. And the post-industrial, the good thing really about the post-industrial is that you exactly know the content.

Christine Woerner

So you, if you buy the post-industrial, you know exactly it's either from your own spinning mill. You know the yarn waste. You know from which fabric it. You know the yarn waste. You know from which fabric it's coming. You also have a big amount of the post-industrial because you can buy all the weaving salvage or all the fabric cuttings. But on the other hand, this resource or this source is limited, and the post-industrial and also the pre-consumer is almost unlimited. So this is how we make the the definition, and we have. It in the terminology, which we are happy to share with everyone.

Madelaine Thomas

Thanks, Christine. Another question here. I think there's regulations on the mind. Would this data be used in digital product passports? I guess it's hard to tell, right, with all the information not out there yet.

Christine Woerner

Yeah, unfortunately not. So I had several discussions, and this is exactly. The, let's say, the challenge. Because the digital passport is very important, and it will tell you with the certifications, it will give you a lot of transparency about where the product is coming, so it's it's absolutely valid. But it doesn't tell you anything about the quality, so it just tells you how much. And at the moment, maybe that would be something we could discuss, because at the moment it's just recycled. It's not even post-industrial, so the waste source is not included. That at least would give you some identification. But we have some ideas, and we would actually add, like to add to the digital passport a quality level, let's say. At the moment, it's it's not officially planned for the first release.

Madelaine Thomas

Interesting. Thanks, Christine. And then a final question, because we said we're running out of time. How could a classification change the way brands and mills specify and buy recycled cotton?

Christine Woerner

This is very important for me because when you go, the spinners are in a very difficult situation because they are also the the weavers and the knitters, and they they have their requirements from the retailers, mostly. For the government makers, and they have to supply what is required because competition is huge in every country. Competition nowadays is really huge, but it is impossible. I saw requirements from brands which were practically the same than for virgin cotton, and this is impossible. So, if we start understanding and looking actually into the matrix, Understanding what is possible and what not, and how the quality is different. Then you can also add or adjust your requirements. It's it's for me one of the most critical points. The requirement must fit to the raw material, and the raw material must fit to the application. And by the way, we are happy to have discussions, and we do have. Discussions with retailers or all interested parties, and stress a little more about this topic. So we think the classing matrix can add a lot on the requirements and therefore on how to source material.

Madelaine Thomas

Thanks, Christine. We have one other really interesting question, actually, that I want to just get into. I know I said that was the last one. I do apologize, but this one's just come in. So who would need to agree to a standardised quality classification? For it to work.

Christine Woerner

Sorry, can you repeat? That?

Madelaine Thomas

Who would need to agree to a standardised quality classification for it to work at scale?

Christine Woerner

I think actually no one, because what we have today is what we call the Uster statistic, and we do have that for virgin cotton.

Madelaine Thomas

Now we didn't have enough samples to make a statistic because you need a lot of. The database must be much bigger, and the biggest challenge is that the recycled material has so much variation, as you saw, that this is very difficult. But the classification, the matrix, is a trial from our side to compensate. So it's in a way it's a useful statistic, and you can you can tell your, I mean, in the end, the buyers. Must use or can use the classification matrix. And tell them, "Please use, or I want to buy cotton recycled fibers from this class." And then you can start discussing. It's much better than just buying and having no idea. If you if you don't get the material, then you find out what is the class, can you work with it? And then you go into a discussion where you actually have facts and results.

Christine Woerner

Then you can say, "Okay, this didn't work for me. The length has to be a little longer. Short fiber content needs to be lower, or whatever. It doesn't matter." But then you can use this and come into a discussion, and then we can start improving the quality. But I think to standardize, it's really about the market situation. You can use it and just tell your suppliers. This is what I would like. Do you think you can do it or not? And then adjust your expectations in a way. I mean, did it answer the question?

Madelaine Thomas

It did, indeed. Thank you so much. All right. Thank you for your insights and for sharing, especially that classification matrix with us all. So, thank you also to our audience and for your brilliant questions there as well. We will sign off now. Our next speaker will build on this theme of standardisation. Across the value chain, and we'll see you back here in 15 minutes at 12pm UTC. Thanks again, everyone.